10 Tips to help Select Your Rhinoplasty Surgeon

This article is intended for Canadian residents only. Information provided on this site is for education and is not designed or intended to constitute medical advice, or to be used for diagnosis. Full Disclaimer information is available at on the Disclaimer and Copyright page

Rhinoplasty, commonly known as nose reshaping surgery, is widely regarded as one of the most complex and technically demanding cosmetic procedures. Achieving outcomes that are both aesthetically pleasing and functionally sound requires a surgeon with exceptional skill, extensive training, and a nuanced understanding of facial harmony. Consequently, the selection process for a rhinoplasty surgeon is paramount, directly impacting patient safety, satisfaction, and the ultimate success of the procedure.

Choosing Your Rhinoplasty Surgeon in Canada: 10 Essential Tips

Selecting the right surgeon is one of the most important decision a patient makes when considering rhinoplasty. The following ten tips provide a framework for navigating this process in Canadian.

Tip 1: Verify College Certification and Specialization

The cornerstone of verifying a surgeon's qualifications in Canada lies in confirming their certification status with the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada (RCPSC) and provincial College. The RCPSC is the national body responsible for setting standards and accrediting residency programs for medical specialties across the country. Certification by the RCPSC signifies that a surgeon has successfully completed years of rigorous, supervised residency training in their designated specialty and has passed comprehensive written and oral examinations designed to assess their knowledge and competence.

For rhinoplasty in Canada, two primary RCPSC-certified specialties provide the necessary training:

1.     Plastic Surgery: Surgeons certified in Plastic Surgery complete a minimum five-year RCPSC-accredited residency program following medical school. This training encompasses a broad range of reconstructive and cosmetic procedures across the entire body, including dedicated training in aesthetic surgery, head and neck reconstruction, and craniofacial surgery. While their training is comprehensive, plastic surgeons often develop sub-specializations, including facial plastic surgery.

2.     Otolaryngology – Head and Neck Surgery (Oto-HNS / ENT): This specialty also involves a five-year RCPSC-accredited residency program. Critically, training in facial plastic and reconstructive surgery, including rhinoplasty and septorhinoplasty (addressing both form and function), is an integral and required component of Oto-HNS residency in Canada and the USA. These specialists possess a deep understanding of nasal anatomy, physiology, and respiratory function.

While both RCPSC-certified Plastic Surgeons and Otolaryngologist-Head and Neck Surgeons are qualified experts to perform rhinoplasty in Canada, understanding their foundational training provides context and can help choose what is right for you. Otolaryngologists bring an intrinsic depth of knowledge regarding nasal function, which is crucial since rhinoplasty must preserve or improve breathing. Plastic Surgeons possess broad training in aesthetic principles across the body, which informs their approach to facial harmony. One is not better than the other, in fact, both specialists are equally qualified and trained to perform Rhinoplasty.

Beyond the fundamental RCPSC certification, look for evidence of further specialization through Fellowship Training. Completing a fellowship in Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery demonstrates an additional one to two years of dedicated, advanced training focused specifically on aesthetic and reconstructive procedures of the face, head, and neck, including complex rhinoplasty techniques. Organizations like the American Academy of Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery (AAFPRS) oversee prestigious fellowship programs. Holding fellowship credentials, or specific fellowship completion, signals a surgeon's heightened commitment and expertise in this area.

It is crucial for patients to be wary of ambiguous terminology. The title "cosmetic surgeon" is not a recognized specialty certification by the RCPSC or the American Board of Medical Specialties (ABMS). While some qualified surgeons may use the term, it can also be employed by physicians lacking the rigorous, accredited surgical training specific to Plastic Surgery or Otolaryngology-HNS. When a surgeon advertises as "board-certified," patients in Canada should confirm this refers specifically to RCPSC certification in either Plastic Surgery or Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery.

Membership in professional societies such as the Canadian Society of Plastic Surgeons (CSPS) , the Canadian Society of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery (CSOHNS) , the Canadian Society for Aesthetic Plastic Surgery (CSAPS) , or the CAFPRS can further indicate a surgeon's engagement in their field and commitment to ongoing education and ethical standards. However, these memberships supplement, rather than replace, the foundational requirement of RCPSC certification. A clear hierarchy exists: RCPSC certification is the essential baseline in Canada ; recognized fellowships denote advanced, focused training ; and society memberships reflect professional engagement and adherence to peer-group standards.

Patients should always verify a surgeon's credentials and licensure status directly with the College of Physicians and Surgeons in their respective province.

Tip 2: Evaluate Deep Experience in Rhinoplasty (Beyond General Surgery)

Given the intricacies of rhinoplasty , a surgeon's general surgical experience is less indicative of proficiency than their specific, dedicated experience with this particular procedure.

Patients should inquire how much of the surgeon's practice is devoted to rhinoplasty; some sources suggest seeking surgeons for whom rhinoplasty constitutes a significant portion, perhaps 60% or more, of their caseload. Surgeons who limit their practice primarily or exclusively to rhinoplasty often achieve a higher level of mastery due to focused repetition and exposure to diverse challenges. A high volume of general cosmetic procedures does not automatically translate to expertise in the unique demands of nose reshaping.

Quantifying experience is also important. Ask potential surgeons about the approximate number of rhinoplasty procedures they perform annually and have performed throughout their career. While there is no magic number, a higher volume generally correlates with refined techniques, better judgment, and increased comfort handling a wide array of nasal anatomies and complexities.

Furthermore, inquire about the surgeon's experience with cases similar to your own. This could involve specific aesthetic concerns (e.g., dorsal hump reduction, tip refinement, nostril shaping), functional issues (e.g., deviated septum), revision rhinoplasty (correcting previous surgeries), or considerations related to ethnicity (e.g., preserving unique characteristics while achieving aesthetic goals).

A crucial, yet often overlooked, aspect of experience is the surgeon's revision rate. Ask surgeons what percentage of their primary rhinoplasty patients require a subsequent revision procedure. Rhinoplasty is known to have a higher revision rate than many other cosmetic surgeries due to its complexity and the unpredictability of healing. A rate around 10% is generally considered within the normal and typical range for experienced surgeons. A surgeon's willingness to openly discuss their revision rate demonstrates transparency and a realistic understanding of the procedure's challenges. Be cautious of surgeons who claim impossibly low or zero revision rates, or those who are evasive about the topic. The conversation itself provides valuable insight into the surgeon's honesty and approach.

I tell my patients, if a surgeon tells you their revision rate is 0%, they are either lying or they don’t do enough surgery.

Finally, consider indicators of ongoing commitment to the field, such as involvement in teaching surgical residents or fellows, participation in research, or contributions to advancing rhinoplasty techniques. These activities often signify a surgeon who is deeply invested in their specialty and stays abreast of the latest developments.

Tip 3: Assess the Surgeon's Aesthetic Approach (Aligning Vision with Skill)

Rhinoplasty is as much an art as it is a science. Therefore, assessing a surgeon's aesthetic sensibility and ensuring it aligns with your desired outcome is critical. The most direct way to evaluate this is by reviewing the surgeon's before-and-after photo gallery of previous rhinoplasty patients. It is important to remember that patients must give consent to show their photos. Surgeons who practice in smaller cities and towns may have fewer photographs available due to confidentiality concerns and not necessarily due to lack of experience.

Pay close attention to the quality and consistency of the photographs. Images should be high-resolution, well-lit, and taken against a consistent, plain background. Avoid surgeons whose galleries contain blurry, poorly lit, or inconsistently angled photos, or images that appear overly edited or use "glamour shot" effects that obscure detail.

Both the "before" and "after" shots for each patient should use the same lighting, background, and, crucially, the same angles or poses. Comparing a profile view before with a frontal view after, for instance, makes meaningful assessment impossible. Look for galleries that showcase multiple standard views for each patient, typically including frontal, profile (left and right), three-quarter/oblique (left and right), and basal (from below) views. The more angles shown, the more comprehensive the evaluation.

Evaluate the results themselves. Do the outcomes look natural and harmonious with the rest of the patient's facial features? The goal of modern rhinoplasty is typically to create a nose that blends seamlessly with the face, enhancing overall balance rather than drawing attention to itself. Look for consistency in achieving balanced proportions and avoiding tell-tale signs of surgery, such as an overly scooped bridge, a pinched tip, or excessively upturned nostrils. Assess symmetry and scar visibility (especially in open rhinoplasty, where a small scar is placed on the columella).

While invaluable, before-and-after photos have limitations. Individual anatomy, skin thickness, and healing patterns significantly influence the final outcome, meaning one patient's result cannot be perfectly replicated on another. Therefore, it is highly beneficial to discuss specific photos from the gallery with the surgeon during your consultation. This allows them to explain the nuances of each case, the techniques employed, and how those results might relate (or not relate) to the possibilities for your unique situation.

Some surgeons also utilize computer imaging during consultations to simulate potential changes on photos of the patient. This tool can be helpful for visualizing goals and facilitating communication, but it serves as a planning aid, not a guarantee of the final result.

Tip 4: Leverage Patient Reviews and Testimonials Strategically (Beyond Star Ratings)

Patient reviews offer valuable insights into the experiences of others, but they should be evaluated thoughtfully and cautiously. Prioritize reviews found on credible, independent third-party platforms such as RealSelf.com, Google Business Profiles. Sites like RateMD and RealSelf tend to be more anonymous and thus, poor reviews must be taken with a grain of salt. RateMD also has more complex features as physicians can pay to have some poor reviews hidden.

 In Ontario, physicians are prohibited by the CPSO from having testimonials featured directly on a surgeon's own website, therefore the lack of testimonials doesn’t mean they don’t exist.

Look beyond simple star ratings and delve into detailed narrative reviews. These often provide richer context about the patient's entire journey, including their experience during the consultation, the surgical process, the recovery period, interactions with the surgeon and staff, and their ultimate satisfaction with both the aesthetic and functional outcomes. Look for consistency in feedback; multiple reviews highlighting similar positive aspects (e.g., surgeon's attentiveness, staff professionalism, natural-looking results) carry more weight than isolated glowing or negative comments.

Reviews are particularly useful for gauging aspects not easily assessed through photos, such as the surgeon's communication style and bedside manner. Look for comments describing whether the surgeon listened patiently, explained procedures clearly, showed empathy, and made the patient feel comfortable and respected. Phrases indicating the patient felt heard and valued are positive indicators.

If possible, seek out reviews from patients who underwent a similar type of rhinoplasty (e.g., revision, ethnic) or had similar initial concerns. While individual results differ, reviews collectively paint a picture of the consistency of the patient experience – the reliability of the communication, the level of care, and the professionalism of the surgeon and their team. They reflect the overall process of care delivered by the practice.

Another important consideration is the ratio of negative to positive reviews. I believe this is one of the most important features. Although unethical and against some organizations policies, some physicians and clinics offer rewards for positive reviews.

Surgeon’s with very high number of reviews must be viewed with caution and ensure you read the context of the reviews, focus on the detailed, high quality reviews. Related to this is the unhappy customer effect. Happy customers usually go home and don’t think twice about their experience, while unhappy customers can leave and stew. I am sure we have all been there. It takes far more happy patients to leave a positive review than it does for an unhappy patient to leave a negative review. So, for each positive review, assume there are 20 other happy patients. For each negative review, assume 2-3 unhappy patients.

Also, observe if the practice actively responds to reviews on platforms like Google My Business. Professional and thoughtful responses to both positive and negative feedback demonstrate accountability and a commitment to patient engagement. However, it is important to understand that Physicians may not leave responses due to patient confidentiality concerns. In Canada, physicians need to be very careful when responding in order to avoid any potential risk of identifying a patient. A lack of a response doesn’t always mean a doctor doesn’t care, it may simply be to avoid issues with professionalism and confidentiality.

Finally, don't discount word-of-mouth recommendations from trusted sources like friends, family members who have undergone the procedure, or other physicians (like your family doctor) who may have knowledge of reputable specialists in the local medical community.

A comprehensive assessment involves triangulating information from multiple sources. Combine the aesthetic insights gained from before-and-after photos with the experiential insights from detailed patient reviews , and validate these impressions during your personal consultation. Relying on only one data point provides an incomplete picture.

Tip 5: Maximize the Consultation (Your Opportunity for Clarity and Connection)

The consultation is arguably the most critical interaction in the surgeon selection process. It is a two-way evaluation: you assess the surgeon, and the surgeon assesses your candidacy, goals, and expectations. To make the most of this meeting:

●       Come Prepared: Develop a list of questions covering all aspects of the process. Include questions about the surgeon's qualifications (Tip 1), experience (Tip 2), revision rate (Tip 2), proposed surgical technique (e.g., open vs. closed , use of grafts ), potential risks and complications , anesthesia details , recovery expectations , follow-up care plan , and a detailed breakdown of all associated costs (surgeon fee, anesthesia fee, facility fee).

●       Articulate Your Goals: Clearly communicate what you dislike about your nose and what changes you hope to achieve. Bringing photos of noses you find aesthetically pleasing can be helpful for discussion, but understand that exact replication is impossible due to individual anatomy. It is important to have realistic expectations about this.

●       Assess Communication and Rapport: This is your chance to directly evaluate the surgeon's communication style. Do they listen attentively to your concerns?. Do they explain complex medical information in a way you can understand?. Most importantly, do you feel comfortable, respected, and that you are establishing a positive rapport?. This connection is crucial for navigating the surgical journey together.

●       Evaluate Honesty and Realism: A trustworthy surgeon will be upfront about the potential risks and complications specific to your case. They should also provide a realistic assessment of what can be achieved based on your unique nasal structure, skin type, and overall facial features. Be wary of surgeons who minimize risks, offer guarantees of satisfaction, or make promises that seem too good to be true.

●       Understand the Plan: Ensure you leave the consultation with a clear understanding of the surgeon's recommended surgical plan, why they recommend that approach, and what the recovery process entails.

During the consultation, be alert for potential red flags.

These include:

1)     evasiveness regarding qualifications or experience

2)     reluctance to discuss risks

3)     undue pressure to schedule surgery or add procedures

4)     dismissal of your concerns

5)     a lack of personalized assessment.

If you encounter these issues, it is wise to seek a second opinion.

Tip 6: Confirm Hospital Privileges (A Crucial Safety Indicator)

Verifying that a surgeon holds hospital privileges is a critical safety check, regardless of whether your surgery is planned in a hospital or a private surgical facility. Hospital privileges signify that the surgeon has undergone a rigorous credentialing process by a hospital's review committee. This committee independently evaluates the surgeon's education, training, experience, licensure, competence, and safety record to ensure they meet the hospital's standards for performing specific procedures, such as rhinoplasty, within their facility. This provides an additional layer of quality assurance beyond board certification, involving peer review and assessment of ongoing competency.

Crucially, holding hospital privileges provides a vital safety net. In the rare event that a complication arises during or after surgery performed in a private clinic, a surgeon with privileges can admit the patient to the affiliated hospital and continue to manage their care directly. A surgeon without these privileges would not be permitted to treat their patient within the hospital setting should complications necessitate admission, potentially leading to delays or fragmented care.

Patients should directly ask prospective surgeons if they maintain active privileges to perform rhinoplasty at an accredited local hospital. It is also advisable to verify this information independently by contacting the hospital's medical staff office. Most reputable, RCPSC-certified surgeons maintain hospital privileges as a standard practice. A lack of current hospital privileges for the specific procedure being considered should be viewed as a significant concern. Furthermore, operating in accredited non-hospital surgical facilities often mandates that the surgeon holds privileges at a nearby hospital, underscoring the interconnectedness of these safety measures.

Tip 7: Ensure the Out of Hospital Surgical Facility is Accredited

Equally important as the surgeon's qualifications is the safety and preparedness of the environment where the surgery will take place. Whether in a hospital operating room or a private surgical clinic, the facility should be accredited by a recognized, independent body. Accreditation signifies that the facility adheres to stringent standards designed to protect patient safety, often meeting or exceeding those found in hospitals.

These standards typically cover:

●       Facility Design and Maintenance: Adequate space, proper lighting, appropriate flooring and wall surfaces for disinfection, cleanliness, and unimpeded patient transport.

●       Equipment: Availability and proper maintenance of essential surgical and anesthetic equipment, including certified anesthesia machines, patient monitoring devices (ECG, blood pressure, oxygen saturation), defibrillators, resuscitation equipment, and emergency power sources.

●       Staffing: Requirements for appropriately qualified and certified personnel, including RCPSC-certified anesthesiologists for general anesthesia and sedation, certified surgical nurses, and staff trained in emergency protocols like Advanced Cardiac Life Support (ACLS).

●       Safety Protocols: Established procedures for sterilization, infection control, medication handling, emergency response, and patient monitoring during and after surgery.

In Canada, several organizations accredit surgical facilities, and the specific body may depend on the province and the type of facility (e.g., private ambulatory centre vs. publicly funded clinic). Examples include:

●       Canadian Association for Accreditation of Ambulatory Surgical Facilities (CAAASF): A national, voluntary organization setting standards for private surgical clinics. CAAASF accreditation ensures facilities meet rigorous criteria for safety, equipment, and staffing.

●       Provincial College Programs: Many provincial Colleges of Physicians and Surgeons have their own accreditation programs for out-of-hospital premises (OHPs) where certain procedures are performed. Examples include the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario's (CPSO) OHP Inspection Program and the College of Physicians and Surgeons of British Columbia's (CPSBC) Non-Hospital Medical and Surgical Facilities Accreditation Program (NHMSFAP). The NHMSFAP has notably achieved accreditation from the International Society for Quality in Health Care External Evaluation Association (ISQua EEA), signifying adherence to international best practices.

●       Accreditation Canada: This body may be involved in accrediting certain types of facilities, such as Integrated Community Health Services Centres (ICHSCs) in Ontario, sometimes overlapping with provincial college oversight.

Patients should ask the surgeon where the rhinoplasty will be performed and explicitly confirm that the facility holds current accreditation from a relevant and recognized body. Verifying both the surgeon's credentials (Tip 1) and the facility's accreditation (Tip 7) provides comprehensive assurance regarding safety standards for both the practitioner and the surgical environment.

Tip 8: Understand Different Surgical Backgrounds (Context for Expertise)

As established in Tip 1, qualified rhinoplasty surgeons in Canada typically come from one of two RCPSC-certified backgrounds: Plastic Surgery or Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery. While both pathways provide the necessary foundation, understanding their nuances can offer context.

Otolaryngologists (ENTs) receive extensive training focused specifically on the complex anatomy and physiology of the head and neck, with a particular emphasis on the nasal cavity and airway function. Their residency inherently involves managing both functional (breathing) and aesthetic aspects of the nose.

Plastic Surgeons undergo broader training covering aesthetic and reconstructive procedures across the entire body. Their expertise lies in principles of tissue handling, aesthetics, and reconstruction, which they apply to various areas, including the face.

Many surgeons from both backgrounds pursue additional fellowship training specifically in Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery. This post-residency specialization serves as a strong indicator of a surgeon's deep commitment to mastering facial procedures, including advanced rhinoplasty techniques. It signifies significant extra time dedicated to refining skills in this specific anatomical region.

Therefore, rather than focusing solely on the initial residency pathway, patients should prioritize the combination of RCPSC certification in a relevant specialty (Plastic Surgery or Oto-HNS) plus demonstrable, focused experience and/or fellowship training specifically in rhinoplasty and facial plastic surgery. A patient whose primary concern involves significant breathing issues might initially feel more drawn to an Otolaryngologist due to their deep functional expertise. Conversely, a patient focused purely on aesthetic changes might consider surgeons from both backgrounds equally, weighing factors like aesthetic portfolio alignment and specific rhinoplasty experience. However, highly specialized surgeons, regardless of their initial residency, typically possess expertise in addressing both form and function effectively.

Tip 9: Discuss Realistic Outcomes, Risks, and Recovery Thoroughly

A successful rhinoplasty experience hinges on clear communication and well-managed expectations. It is vital to have a frank discussion with your surgeon about realistic outcomes. Rhinoplasty aims for improvement, balance, and facial harmony, not unattainable perfection or the exact replication of a celebrity's nose. A responsible surgeon will explain the limitations imposed by your unique anatomy, bone structure, cartilage quality, and skin thickness.

Equally important is a comprehensive understanding of potential risks and complications.

While generally safe when performed by a qualified surgeon, all surgery carries risks. For rhinoplasty, these may include, but are not limited to: bleeding, infection, adverse reaction to anesthesia, persistent numbness of skin, poor wound healing or unfavorable scarring, skin discoloration, breathing difficulties (nasal obstruction), septal perforation (a hole in the nasal septum), and dissatisfaction with the cosmetic appearance, potentially requiring revision surgery. A reputable surgeon will discuss these potential issues openly and honestly during the consultation. A failure to adequately address risks is a significant red flag.

Thoroughly understanding the recovery process is also essential for preparation and adherence to post-operative instructions. Discuss the typical timeline, including:

●       Initial period: Wearing a cast or splint, nasal packing (sometimes), bruising and swelling (most prominent in the first week or two).

●       Activity restrictions: Avoiding strenuous exercise, heavy lifting, contact sports, blowing your nose forcefully, swimming, wearing glasses directly on the bridge (initially), excessive sun exposure, and smoking (which impairs healing).

●       Healing progression: Gradual reduction of swelling over weeks and months, with final subtle refinements potentially taking up to a year or even longer to become fully apparent.

●       Post-operative care: Instructions for cleaning, medication use (pain relief, antibiotics), managing congestion (e.g., saline sprays), sleeping position (head elevated), and follow-up appointment schedule.

Successful outcomes are a shared responsibility between the surgeon and the patient. Diligently following post-operative instructions is crucial for minimizing complications, facilitating proper healing, and achieving the desired result. The recovery period also involves a psychological adjustment to the change in appearance, which can be eased by having realistic expectations and understanding that the final result emerges gradually over time.

Tip 10: Trust Your Instincts on Communication and Comfort

Beyond the objective criteria of credentials, experience, and facility accreditation, the subjective element of your personal connection with the surgeon is profoundly important. Rhinoplasty is a significant personal decision and a journey you undertake with your surgeon. Feeling comfortable, confident, and trusting in your chosen surgeon is vital for a positive experience.

During the consultation and subsequent interactions, pay attention to how you feel. Does the surgeon communicate in a style that resonates with you? Do you feel genuinely heard and that your goals and concerns are understood and respected?. Do you feel confident in their expertise and judgment?. Do you trust that they will provide attentive and supportive care throughout the process, especially if any challenges or complications arise?

Consider the overall impression of the practice as well. Is the office staff professional, organized, and helpful? They are an integral part of your care team.

Achieving a result that aligns with the patient's aesthetic goals fundamentally relies on effective two-way communication. The surgeon must accurately understand the patient's desires, and the patient must understand the realistic possibilities. This mutual understanding is built on a foundation of good rapport and clear communication established during the consultation process.

Do not hesitate to seek second opinions from other qualified surgeons. Comparing different perspectives and interaction styles can help solidify your choice and ensure you find the surgeon who is the best fit for you, both technically and personally. Ultimately, while objective qualifications are non-negotiable, your intuition about the surgeon-patient relationship should not be ignored.

Dr James P Bonaparte, MD, MSc, FRCSC